A request for proposal is the document a buyer sends to several agencies so each one answers the same questions, prices the same scope and can be scored on the same sheet. For a marketing or website project it should sit inside your wider digital strategy, because an agency can only propose against goals you have actually written down.

Most online pages offering a request for proposal template are written by US agencies and stop at a list of headings. This guide adds what a South African buyer needs on top: a weighted scoring sheet with a worked example, a VAT-inclusive way to compare quotes, and the data-handling and account-ownership clauses that decide who holds your assets when the contract ends.

Quick Answer

A request for proposal for a marketing or website agency states your goals, scope, budget range, timeline, the questions each agency must answer and the criteria you will score them on. Send it to a short list of agencies, ask for prices in the same format with VAT shown as a separate line, and score every response with the weights you published. The format matters less than the rule that every agency answers the same questions.

Not sure your goals are RFP-ready?

Send us your draft goals and scope and we will point out where an agency would have to guess.

Request a Free Consultation

What Is a Request for Proposal, and How Does It Differ From a Brief?

A request for proposal is a formal, comparable invitation to bid: you describe the problem and the rules, and agencies reply with an approach and a price. WebFX defines a marketing request for proposal as "a written document that businesses share with marketing agencies to get quotes for a project or campaign", covering scope, deliverables, deadlines and budget.

Four documents get confused, and sending the wrong one wastes everyone's time:

DocumentWhat it doesBest for
Project briefYour internal definition of goals, audience and requirements, written firstAligning your own team; see the website project brief template
RFI (request for information)Asks agencies about capability, with no price and no commitmentBuilding a shortlist when you do not know the market
RFPAsks shortlisted agencies for an approach, team and price against your scopeProjects where the method is open and you want to compare thinking
RFQ (request for quotation)Asks for a price on a fully fixed specificationDefined work such as a set of page templates or a fixed ad-account setup

If your scope is fully defined, a quotation request is enough. If you are not yet sure what you need, write the brief first. Use a proposal request when the approach is genuinely open and you want to see how each agency would solve it.

This guide is for private-sector buyers. If you are an organ of state, tenders fall under the Preferential Procurement Policy Framework Act and its regulations, which set their own points-based scoring, so your supply chain office, not this post, governs the format.

What Should an Agency Brief Contain?

An agency request for proposal should contain everything an agency needs to price the work without guessing, and nothing that belongs in your internal strategy. WebFX lists eleven sections for a marketing RFP, from statement of purpose through reply requirements; the table below condenses them into the eight that matter for a marketing or website project and says what to write in each.

SectionWhat to writeWhy an agency needs it
1. Business contextWhat you sell, to whom, where, and what has been tried alreadyLets the agency judge fit and avoid repeating past failures
2. Goals and measuresThe outcome in business terms, and the number you will judge it byProposals can only target what you define. See marketing goals vs KPIs
3. Scope and exclusionsDeliverables in, deliverables out, and what you already own (domain, hosting, ad accounts)Removes the biggest cause of quotes that cannot be compared
4. Technical and platform constraintsCurrent platform, integrations, payment gateways, tracking set-upSurfaces hidden work before pricing
5. Budget and timelineA range, the launch date and the reason for itAgencies scope to a number rather than guess one
6. Response formatPage limit, price table layout, prices with VAT shown as a separate line, required attachmentsMakes responses scoreable side by side
7. Questions for agenciesFive to eight specific questions, including who does the work and what is subcontractedForces specifics instead of a capabilities deck
8. Evaluation and processCriteria and weights, the question deadline, the decision date, one contact personAgencies self-select out if they cannot meet the rules

Keep it short. Major Tom, a web agency, says the strongest briefs it receives are typically 6 to 15 pages. As a working view, a much longer document usually means the buyer has not yet decided what matters.

Vague requirement: "We need a modern, user-friendly website that increases sales and integrates with our systems."

Specific requirement: "Rebuild our store's checkout and product pages. Today we take payments through [gateway], ship with [courier] and track purchases in [analytics tool]. State whether connecting each of these is in your price or an add-on."

The second version names the payment gateway, courier and analytics tool (a South African store might fill those in with PayFast, The Courier Guy and GA4), so every agency prices the same job.

Key Takeaway

A strong RFP works by removing choices the agency would otherwise make for itself. Every ambiguity you leave in the scope becomes a different assumption in each quote, and you end up comparing assumptions instead of agencies.

Should You Publish a Budget Range to Agencies?

Publishing a budget range means telling every agency the ceiling you can defend, so each proposes to your real constraint instead of guessing and padding. Our recommendation is to publish a range. Major Tom puts it bluntly: "Hidden budgets are the single biggest reason RFPs produce mismatched proposals." The cost of hiding it is a spread of quotes that reflect each agency's guess about you.

The worry is that a stated budget gets spent. The fix is to ask for itemised pricing, so you can see what each part costs and drop modules to fit. If you do not know a realistic range, get your reference points first from website cost in South Africa, marketing retainer costs and consultant hourly rates, then set a range with a ceiling you can defend.

How Do You Score Agency Responses?

A scoring sheet turns a pile of persuasive documents into a ranking you can defend to a partner or board, by fixing the criteria and weights before you open any response. Major Tom suggests publishing the framework in the RFP and lists price, relevant experience, proposed approach, team, references and cultural fit as the dimensions.

The weights below are a working rule of thumb, not a standard. Change them to match your project, but set them before the responses arrive. Treat any legal must-have, such as agreeing to a written POPIA operator contract where the agency processes personal information for you, as pass or fail rather than as points a strong price can buy back.

CriterionWeight (points out of 100)What a top score looks like
Approach and understanding30Restates your problem correctly and proposes a method specific to it
Price and value25Itemised, VAT shown as a separate line, nothing important left as an add-on
Relevant proof and references20Comparable work you can verify by phoning the client
Team and capacity15Named people who will do the work, with stated availability
Commercial terms10Clear asset ownership, exit and handover terms

Worked example: why the cheapest response can lose

Score each criterion from 1 to 5, using a written definition of what each score means so two scorers do not read the same answer differently. Multiply by the weight and divide by 5. Agency A scores approach 4, proof 3, team 4, price 5 and terms 3, which gives 24 + 12 + 12 + 25 + 6 = 79 points. Agency B scores approach 5, proof 4, team 3, price 3 and terms 5, which gives 30 + 16 + 9 + 15 + 10 = 80 points.

Agency A has the strongest price score and still loses by a point, because Agency B's method and terms carry more weight. A margin that thin is a prompt to re-check the weights and test both agencies further, not an automatic win for B. The sheet makes the trade-off visible, so the decision is a conversation about weights rather than a hunch. These scores are hypothetical and show the arithmetic only.

Key Takeaway

A weighted scoring sheet, agreed before responses arrive, lets you defend choosing a dearer agency and stops a low price from deciding the outcome by default. The weights are yours to set, but they must be fixed and published before anyone sees a quote.

Have two or three people score independently before comparing, so the loudest voice in the room does not set the result. Then use the shortlist presentations to test the top two on the criteria where their scores sit furthest apart. Our list of questions to ask a marketing agency is a good source for those sessions.

Want a second pair of eyes on your scoring weights?

Tell us the project and the agencies you are weighing and we will assess whether your criteria match your real risks.

Ask for a Free Consultation

Which South African Requirements Belong in the Document?

Four South African points belong in an agency brief: how VAT is shown, a written POPIA operator contract, who owns the accounts and assets, and B-BBEE only where you need it. Generic templates skip them, and each changes either the price you compare or the risk you carry.

VAT shown separately

Asking every agency for both the VAT-exclusive and VAT-inclusive price lets you compare like with like, since some agencies are VAT-registered and some are not. The SARS VAT page gives the standard rate as 15%, and compulsory registration starts at R2.3 million in taxable supplies from 1 April 2026.

A quote of R100,000 excluding VAT is R115,000 once VAT is added. A flat R110,000 from a supplier not charging VAT is R5,000 cheaper on its face. Collect both figures in the price table. If you are a VAT vendor and can claim the VAT as input tax, compare the VAT-exclusive prices. If you cannot, compare the VAT-inclusive totals, because that is what you will pay. Confirm your own position with your accountant.

A written POPIA operator contract

Where an agency processes personal information for you, such as your CRM, email list, ad audiences or analytics data, a written contract is a legal requirement, not a courtesy.

Section 21(1) of POPIA requires a responsible party to ensure, through a written contract, that an operator processing personal information for it maintains the section 19 security measures. Section 21(2) requires the operator to notify you immediately where there are reasonable grounds to believe personal information has been accessed or acquired by an unauthorised person. Ask each agency to confirm in its response that it will sign an operator agreement, and treat a refusal as disqualifying. See our guide to the POPIA operator agreement for what it covers.

Who owns the accounts and assets

Ownership of your domain, hosting, ad accounts, analytics property and creative files should sit in your name from day one, with the agency given access. Ask each respondent to state in writing which assets they will hold, which you will hold, and how access is handed over if the relationship ends. For analytics, that means you hold the GA4 property and the agency is added as a user.

B-BBEE, only if you need it

Ask for a B-BBEE certificate or sworn affidavit only if your own customers or supplier-onboarding process require it from you. Requesting it adds paperwork for every agency, and it does not tell you whether they will do the work well. If you do require it, put it in the response-format section so it is not a surprise.

How Should You Run the Selection Process?

A tidy selection process treats every agency identically: the same document, the same deadline, the same answers to questions. Major Tom recommends inviting three to five agencies, saying fewer provides insufficient comparison while more strains resources and deters top-tier firms from competing seriously.

  • Shortlist first. Use your network, directories and our guides to choosing a marketing partner or agency versus freelancer to decide who deserves an invitation.
  • Set a question window. Give agencies a fixed date to ask questions, and send each question and your answer to all of them.
  • One contact person. Side conversations with one agency break the fairness the document is meant to create.
  • Allow for diligence. Phone the references of your top two before you decide, and check the work is what the proposal claims it is.
  • Close the loop. Tell the unsuccessful agencies the outcome. In our view, that courtesy keeps good agencies willing to respond next time.

If the winning agency was not the cheapest, record why against the scoring sheet. When someone later asks about the extra cost, the sheet is your answer.

Shortlisted three agencies and still undecided?

Send us the responses with names removed and we will give you an audit of where each one is vague.

Get a Free Audit

Why South African Businesses Choose Growth Pulse Media

Growth Pulse Media is a Johannesburg agency, so we are on the other side of this document: we respond to briefs as well as advise on them. Weigh this advice with that in mind; the scoring sheet above is built to protect you from our bias as much as anyone's.

Founder Dirk van Greuning built and scaled a large South African ecommerce business before starting the agency, and all work is executed in-house with a limited client load. Our digital strategy service starts with the part a proposal request depends on: goals, measures and scope that an agency can price.

Who This Is Not For

A formal agency selection process suits some buyers and wastes time for others, and these three readers should skip it.

Your scope is one small fixed job. A single landing page or a one-off ad-account setup does not need a formal process. Ask two or three suppliers for a quote against a short brief.

You have no goals or budget yet. A proposal request exposes that gap to every agency at once. Write the brief and the goals first, then come back.

You are an organ of state. Public procurement follows statutory tender rules and your supply chain office's templates. Use this post for ideas on evaluating technical quality only.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a request for proposal in marketing?

In marketing, it is a document a business sends to agencies, describing its goals, scope, budget and timeline so each agency can propose an approach and a price. It lets the buyer compare responses on the same criteria instead of comparing sales pitches.

What should an RFP for a website agency include?

A website request for proposal should include business context, goals and success measures, scope and exclusions, platform and integration constraints, a budget range and launch date, the response format, specific questions for agencies and the criteria you will score them on. Name the platform, payment gateways and courier integrations so every agency prices the same job.

How many agencies should I send the RFP to?

Three to five is the range Major Tom, a web agency, recommends: fewer provides insufficient comparison, while more strains resources and deters top-tier firms from competing seriously. Shortlist with an RFI or reference checks first so every invited agency is a plausible fit.

Should an RFP include my budget?

Yes, include a budget range. Hidden budgets are, in Major Tom's words, "the single biggest reason RFPs produce mismatched proposals". Ask for itemised pricing so you can remove modules if responses come in above the range.

What is the difference between an RFP and a project brief?

A project brief is your own definition of goals, audience and requirements, usually written first for internal alignment. An RFP is the document built from it that you send to agencies, with the response format, questions and scoring criteria added.

Get your RFP ready before you send it

We work with Google Ads, Meta Ads, Shopify, GA4 and Search Console from our Johannesburg base. Send us your draft and we will tell you where an agency would have to guess. No obligation, and we will get back to you within 24 hours.

Talk to Us
Dirk van Greuning — Founder, Growth Pulse Media
Dirk van Greuning Founder, Growth Pulse Media

Founder of Growth Pulse Media and a specialist in South African search dominance. Dirk translates his experience in scaling South African businesses into high-velocity digital strategies for B2B and retail leaders. He writes about SEO, lead generation, and paid media from an operator's perspective — prioritising pipeline value over impressions.

Connect on LinkedIn