404 vs 410 SEO comes down to one fact: Google's documentation treats a 404 (not found) and a 410 (gone) as the same kind of response, so the choice between them is a small one. The larger decision is what happens to a removed URL before it reaches either code, and that decision sits inside your wider SEO for South African businesses.
A 404 says the server cannot find the page. A 410 says the page is gone and is likely to stay that way. For a South African retailer clearing discontinued stock, a property site dropping sold listings, or a business retiring last season's promotion, the useful question is not "404 or 410?" but "redirect, keep, or remove?" This post answers both, in that order of importance.
Quick Answer
For 404 vs 410 SEO, use a 301 redirect when a close replacement page exists, and a 404 or 410 when the page is gone for good. Google says all 4xx errors except 429 are treated the same, so a 410 is optional rather than better. Redirecting removed pages to your homepage is best avoided, because Google's guidance says it might be treated as a soft 404.
In This Post
Not sure which old URLs to redirect?
Send us the list of pages you have removed and we will tell you which deserve a redirect and which can simply go.
Request a Free Audit404 vs 410 SEO: What Each Status Code Tells Google
A status code is the server's one-word answer to a request for a URL, and 404 and 410 are two different answers to "where did this page go?". The HTTP standard (RFC 9110) defines 404 as the server being unable to find the target resource, and 410 as the resource being no longer available at the origin server with the condition "likely to be permanent".
So 410 gone vs 404 not found is a difference of intent, not of outcome. A 404 makes no promise either way, and a missing page may return. A 410 tells the client the removal is deliberate. The standard also says a server is "not obliged to retain knowledge of or provide a forwarding address" for a 410 page, so neither code points a visitor, or a crawler, to a new location. Only a redirect does that.
This is the 404 vs 410 status code distinction in plain terms: 404 means "I can't find it", 410 means "it was here, and it's gone". Google's crawlers read both as "content that does not exist", as the next section shows.
Does Google Remove a Page Faster After a 410 Than a 404?
Google's documentation gives a 410 and a 404 the same treatment and states no timing difference between them. A 2018 comment from Google's John Mueller, reported second-hand by Seer Interactive, suggested a 410 might drop out a couple of days sooner, which is unverified. The Search Central page on HTTP status codes states that "All 4xx errors, except 429, are treated the same" and that crawlers tell the next processing system the content does not exist.
For a 404, the same page says the indexing pipeline removes a previously indexed URL from the index, newly encountered 404s are not processed, and crawling gradually decreases. It lists no separate handling for 410. Three pieces of evidence sit around that documentation:
John Mueller, 2018 (as reported by Seer Interactive): "From our point of view, in the mid term/long term, a 404 is the same as a 410 for us." Seer's write-up adds that a 410 may drop out "a little bit faster" than a 404, by "a couple days".
The second is a controlled test. In Reboot Online's experiment, published in June 2022, 119 test pages across two websites were split between 404 and 410 and watched for three months. The 404 pages were crawled on average 49.6% more often than the 410 pages, statistically significant at 95% confidence.
The team could not measure removal speed, because Search Console's API labelled every removed URL "Not Found (404)" whatever code it actually returned. Treat it as one test on two sites, and as evidence about recrawling only.
The third is the most recent. In March 2026, Search Engine Journal reported Mueller answering a question about 404s being recrawled: "These don't cause problems, so I'd just let them be. They'll be recrawled for potentially a long time, a 410 won't change that."
Takeaway: How Much Does the Code Matter?
Google's documentation groups 404 and 410 together, one controlled test found 404 pages were recrawled 49.6% more often than 410 pages, and Google's Mueller said in 2026 that a 410 will not stop a removed page being recrawled. A 410 is a tidy signal of intent, and Google's documentation gives it no separate handling. Spend your effort on redirects and soft 404s instead.
One caution on the Reboot figure: "49.6% more often" means 404 pages were hit more frequently than 410 pages. It does not say either code harms the rest of your site. Google's page also states that 4xx codes other than 429 have no effect on crawl rate.
Which Status Code Should Each Removed Page Return?
The right response for a removed URL depends on whether a close replacement exists, whether the page could come back, and whether users should still reach it. Google's crawling-errors guidance is to return a 301 when a page has moved, and a 404 or 410 when it is gone with no replacement. The table applies that to situations South African sites run into, so the code itself is only one column of the decision.
| Situation | Return | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| Product renamed, or a near-identical replacement page exists | 301 to the replacement | Keeping visitors and any links the old URL earned |
| Several thin pages merged into one stronger page | 301 to the merged page | Consolidation, where Google accepts redirects to the new combined page |
| Discontinued item with no like-for-like successor | 404, or 410 if you prefer a clear signal | Honest removal; link to the category from the error page |
| Expired listing, vacancy or tender page, gone for good | 410 where your server makes it easy, otherwise 404 | Pages that will not return |
| Seasonal page that may return (a Black Friday landing page, for example) | Keep it live with a "back soon" message, or let it 404 | Pages you will reuse next year |
| Page must stay for users but stay out of Google | 200 with a noindex tag | Thank-you pages, internal tools; see noindex vs robots.txt |
The seasonal row is a working view, not a Google rule: a page you will rebuild in twelve months is usually cheaper to keep than to remove and recreate. If a whole batch of low-value pages needs to go, content pruning covers how to decide which, and the 301 redirect checklist covers the redirect side.
Retiring a batch of pages?
Share your site and the pages you plan to remove, and we will tell you which need a redirect and which can simply go.
Talk to Us About Your SiteHow to Return a 410 on Apache and Why Shopify Defaults to 404
Returning a 410 takes one line on an Apache server, and the method differs on other servers and hosted platforms, which is why many sites settle for a 404. The Apache mod_alias documentation describes the "gone" status as returning 410, "indicating that the resource has been permanently removed", and notes the URL argument should be omitted. Its own example is Redirect gone "/one".
That directive belongs in the Apache server configuration, or in an .htaccess file where your host runs Apache and allows it. Servers such as nginx use different syntax, so on a shared host check what your provider supports before editing anything. Whichever method you use, request the specific URL afterwards and read the response code rather than assuming the rule matched.
On Shopify, plan around 404. Shopify's own help page on URL redirects says "You can redirect only from broken URLs", such as pages showing "Page not found" or "404", and suggests redirecting a deleted product to a similar one.
That page does not mention 410, so for a Shopify store the realistic choices are a redirect to a relevant product or collection, or a 404. Since Google treats the two alike, nothing is lost. If the store is being rebuilt, the Shopify migration SEO guide covers URL mapping.
For larger moves, build the full old-to-new map first; the redirect map checklist and the site migration checklist are the places to start.
How Soft 404s and Homepage Redirects Go Wrong
A soft 404 is a page that tells the visitor it does not exist while the server answers 200 (success), so the server says the page exists when it does not. Google's crawling-errors documentation describes it as a page that "returns a page telling the user that the page does not exist and also a 200 (success) status code". Search Console flags them as soft 404 errors.
One way to create a soft 404 is a custom "Oops, page not found" template that is served with a 200 status. Another is a blanket redirect of every deleted URL to the homepage. Google's site-move guidance says: "Don't redirect many old URLs to one irrelevant single URL destination, such as the home page of the new site", because it can "confuse users and might be treated as a soft 404 error".
Google also says content from a redirecting URL is ignored and the target page's content is processed instead. A homepage redirect therefore hands the visitor, and Google, a page that has nothing to do with the one that was requested.
Wrong (illustrative scenario): a Gauteng retailer clearing last season's stock after a sale, deleting a batch of discontinued product pages and redirecting every one of them to the homepage because "it keeps the traffic". The visitor lands on an unrelated page, and Google may treat each redirect as a soft 404.
Right (same scenario): redirecting each product with a genuine successor to that successor, sending the rest to their closest category page, and letting items with no relevant destination return a real 404 or 410 with a helpful error page.
How to Check What Google Sees After Removing a Page
The only reliable check on a removed URL is to request it and read the status code your server actually returns, then watch how Google reports it. Fetch the URL with your browser's developer tools (Network tab) or any header checker and confirm you see 404, 410 or 301 as intended, not a 200 with an error message.
Then use the Page indexing report in Search Console. Google's help page says the "Not found (404)" report covers only the past month, and that Google keeps attempting to crawl such URLs periodically, so seeing them listed is expected. The Search Console guide walks through the reports. A page flagged "Soft 404" is the one to fix first.
If something must leave Google quickly, the code is the wrong tool. Google's removal documentation lists removing or updating the content, password-protecting the page, or adding a noindex tag, and says requests in the Removals tool last for about 6 months, so they are a stopgap rather than a permanent fix.
Takeaway: The Removal Order of Operations
Decide in this order: is there a close replacement (301), should the page stay for users but not search (noindex), or is it gone (404 or 410)? Then confirm the server returns the code you intended and that Search Console does not show a soft 404. In 404 vs 410 SEO terms, the choice between the two codes is the last and smallest decision.
Want a second opinion on your removed pages?
Request a free audit and we will check the status codes on the URLs you retired and flag any soft 404s.
Request a Free AuditWhy South African Businesses Choose Growth Pulse Media
South African businesses choose Growth Pulse Media for search work that gets senior attention. Growth Pulse Media is a Johannesburg agency founded by Dirk van Greuning, who built and scaled a large South African ecommerce business before starting the agency, so the focus is on what a change does to traffic and enquiries rather than to a report.
All work is executed in-house and the client load is kept limited so that senior people stay on each account. For search work beyond removed pages, see our SEO service.
Who This Is NOT For
This post is not written for readers who expect a status code alone to fix a problem, and the three cases below are the ones to rule out first.
Anyone hoping a 410 will rescue rankings. Google's documentation gives 410 no separate handling from 404, so swapping codes is unlikely to explain or fix a traffic drop. If traffic fell after a site change, look at redirects, indexing and content first.
Anyone who needs a page out of Google urgently. A status code works on Google's schedule. For urgent or sensitive removals, remove the content itself and use the Removals tool described above.
Anyone alarmed by recrawled 404s in their logs. Seeing Google keep requesting removed URLs is not a fault to fix. Mueller's advice on recrawled 404s was to "just let them be", and a 410 will not stop the requests.
Frequently Asked Questions
These answers cover the 404 vs 410 SEO questions South African site owners tend to have when they retire pages, drawing only on the sources cited above.
Is 404 or 410 better for SEO?
Neither is better for SEO in Google's documentation, which says all 4xx errors except 429 are treated the same. Use 410 when you want to signal a deliberate, permanent removal and your server makes it easy. Use 404 when it is simpler, because the practical result is the same.
Does a 410 remove a page from Google faster than a 404?
Google's documentation states no timing difference between them. A 2018 comment from John Mueller, reported by Seer Interactive, suggested a 410 may fall out "a little bit faster", by "a couple days", while the same report has him calling the two the same in the mid to long term. Reboot Online's test measured recrawling, not removal speed.
Should I redirect deleted pages to my homepage?
No, unless the homepage is genuinely the closest relevant page. Google's site-move guidance warns against redirecting many old URLs to one irrelevant destination such as the home page, and says it might be treated as a soft 404. Redirect to a close replacement, or return a 404 or 410.
When to use 410 instead of 404?
Use a 410 when a page is permanently gone, has no replacement and you want the removal to read as deliberate, such as pruned pages or expired listings. Seer Interactive suggests reserving 410 for content pruning or for a stubborn indexed page that you want out faster. Otherwise a 404 is fine.
Do 404 errors hurt my Google rankings?
Not by themselves. Google's documentation says 4xx codes other than 429 do not affect crawl rate, and Mueller said in 2026 that recrawled 404s "don't cause problems". What costs you is a 404 on a page that still earned visits or links, where a 301 to a relevant page would have kept them.
How do I return a 410 on an Apache server?
Add a Redirect gone directive with the old path, for example Redirect gone "/one", in your Apache server configuration, or in .htaccess where your host runs Apache and allows it. Apache's mod_alias documentation says the status returns 410 and the URL argument should be omitted. On nginx the syntax differs, so check with your host, then request the URL to confirm the response.
Get Your Removed Pages Sorted
Send us your site and the list of URLs you have retired. We will check the status codes with Search Console, flag soft 404s and tell you what to redirect. No obligation, and we'll get back to you within 24 hours.
Contact Growth Pulse Media

